New-build home prices in 34251
Recorded home sales in ZIP 34251 (Manatee County) run a median of $322 per square foot, the ground pricing a new-build has to work against. The middle half of sales sit between $264 and $370/sq ft.
What new homes sell for in 34251
At the local median of $322/sq ft, a new home would price roughly:
| 1,500 sq ft | $483,000 |
| 2,000 sq ft | $644,000 |
| 2,500 sq ft | $805,000 |
| 3,000 sq ft | $966,000 |
A gross sale price. The land bid it supports comes after build cost, contingency, fees, finance and profit — the residual the Threshold tool solves.
By home type
| Home type | Sales | Median $/sq ft | Median size | Median price |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Single-family | 35 | $324 | 2,001 sf | $640,000 |
| Mobile / manufactured | 3 | $255 | 1,512 sf | $331,400 |
Recent sales in 34251
| Type | Sq ft | Sale price | $/sq ft | Yr built | Sold |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Single-family | 2,629 | $1,360,000 | $517 | 2017 | 7/2025 |
| Single-family | 2,149 | $1,150,000 | $535 | 2002 | 8/2025 |
| Single-family | 2,641 | $1,062,500 | $402 | 1997 | 9/2025 |
| Single-family | 2,528 | $900,000 | $356 | 2000 | 3/2025 |
| Single-family | 2,028 | $750,000 | $370 | 1993 | 12/2025 |
| Single-family | 2,301 | $715,000 | $311 | 1995 | 4/2025 |
| Single-family | 2,577 | $680,000 | $264 | 2006 | 10/2025 |
| Single-family | 1,824 | $675,000 | $370 | 2024 | 6/2025 |
| Single-family | 1,881 | $640,000 | $340 | 1995 | 11/2025 |
| Single-family | 1,825 | $625,000 | $343 | 1994 | 8/2025 |
| Single-family | 2,326 | $535,000 | $230 | 1977 | 1/2025 |
| Single-family | 1,056 | $510,000 | $483 | 2009 | 3/2025 |
| Single-family | 756 | $453,000 | $599 | 2002 | 3/2025 |
| Single-family | 1,352 | $401,600 | $297 | 1994 | 4/2025 |
| Mobile / manufactured | 1,584 | $331,400 | $209 | 1985 | 6/2025 |
Appraising a site in 34251?
Drop a pin and Threshold US Land turns these comparables into an achievable new-build price and the maximum land bid that still hits your margin — in under 60 seconds.
Reserve founding access →Questions about 34251 home prices
- What is the price per square foot in 34251?
- Recent recorded home sales in ZIP 34251 (Manatee County, FL) run a median of $322 per square foot, with the middle half between $264 and $370, from 38 qualified sales in 2024-2025.
- What does a home sell for in 34251?
- The typical recorded sale in 34251 is a 1,862 sq ft home at $630,000. A new 1,862 sq ft home at the local $322/sq ft would price around $599,564.
- Where does this 34251 data come from?
- Florida Department of Revenue tax rolls, geolocated via the Florida statewide GIS parcel layer. Qualified residential sales from 2024. Estimates for site screening, not an appraisal.
All of Manatee County →
Nearby ZIPs: 34240 · 34202 · 34211 · 34241 · 34212 · 34201 · 34291 · 34235
Florida land hub
Method: qualified, arms-length, improved residential sales (2024+) from Florida Department of Revenue tax rolls, geolocated via the Florida statewide GIS parcel layer, assigned to nearest ZIP centroid. $/sq ft is sale price over heated living area. Estimates for site screening, not a USPAP appraisal. Updated July 2026.