Threshold US · New York land
New-build home prices in Cayuga County
Across Cayuga County, recorded home sales run a median of $113 per square foot (middle half $75-$157), from 2,974 qualified sales. The typical home is 1,618 sq ft selling at $176,700.
$113
median $/sq ft
$176,700
median sale price
1,618
median home size (sq ft)
2,974
qualified sales analyzed
$/sq ft by ZIP
13024$81/sf
847 sales
13021$129/sf
847 sales
13166$114/sf
168 sales
13118$113/sf
155 sales
13160$119/sf
102 sales
13156$131/sf
82 sales
13092$112/sf
77 sales
13140$95/sf
73 sales
13033$106/sf
62 sales
13026$167/sf
62 sales
13113$132/sf
61 sales
13147$141/sf
59 sales
13117$115/sf
56 sales
13081$224/sf
52 sales
13034$122/sf
49 sales
13071$104/sf
28 sales
13111$114/sf
26 sales
By home type
| Home type | Sales | Median $/sq ft | Median size | Median price |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Single-family | 2,619 | $121 | 1,560 sf | $185,000 |
| Multi-family | 355 | $58 | 2,186 sf | $130,000 |
Recent sales across Cayuga County
| Type | Sq ft | Sale price | $/sq ft | Yr built | Sold |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Single-family | 2,664 | $725,000 | $272 | 2010 | 6/2026 |
| Single-family | 2,976 | $685,000 | $230 | 2002 | 3/2026 |
| Single-family | 3,240 | $631,700 | $195 | 1836 | 6/2026 |
| Single-family | 2,456 | $610,000 | $248 | 1990 | 1/2026 |
| Single-family | 2,227 | $475,000 | $213 | 2003 | 1/2026 |
| Single-family | 3,456 | $425,000 | $123 | 1890 | 2/2026 |
| Single-family | 1,600 | $418,000 | $261 | 2007 | 3/2026 |
| Multi-family | 2,004 | $415,000 | $207 | 1900 | 3/2026 |
| Multi-family | 2,954 | $415,000 | $141 | 1804 | 2/2026 |
| Single-family | 3,091 | $415,000 | $134 | 1875 | 2/2026 |
| Single-family | 2,201 | $410,000 | $186 | 1840 | 1/2026 |
| Single-family | 2,150 | $400,000 | $186 | 2003 | 4/2026 |
| Single-family | 2,200 | $395,000 | $180 | 1890 | 4/2026 |
| Single-family | 1,784 | $381,147 | $214 | 1975 | 3/2026 |
| Single-family | 2,046 | $370,000 | $181 | 1995 | 3/2026 |
Appraising a site in Cayuga County?
Threshold US Land turns these comparables into an achievable new-build price and the maximum land bid that hits your margin. Reserve founding access for New York.
Reserve founding access →All New York counties & ZIPs →
Method: arms-length residential sales with assessor living area (2021+) from New York State ORPTS recorded sales joined to the state parcel-centroid layer for living area, plus the New York City annualized sales dataset for the five boroughs. $/sq ft is sale price over heated living area. Estimates for site screening, not a USPAP appraisal. Updated July 2026.