Threshold US · New York land
New-build home prices in Erie County
Across Erie County, recorded home sales run a median of $165 per square foot (middle half $121-$205), from 45,943 qualified sales. The typical home is 1,631 sq ft selling at $250,000.
$165
median $/sq ft
$250,000
median sale price
1,631
median home size (sq ft)
45,943
qualified sales analyzed
$/sq ft by ZIP
14223$171/sf
2,182 sales
14150$154/sf
2,163 sales
14224$168/sf
2,042 sales
14221$198/sf
1,936 sales
14225$169/sf
1,899 sales
14215$104/sf
1,861 sales
14226$180/sf
1,843 sales
14220$126/sf
1,743 sales
14043$162/sf
1,742 sales
14075$187/sf
1,417 sales
14219$171/sf
1,363 sales
14127$198/sf
1,346 sales
14217$158/sf
1,279 sales
14206$115/sf
1,207 sales
14216$155/sf
1,144 sales
14207$96/sf
1,110 sales
14072$182/sf
1,088 sales
14218$119/sf
1,039 sales
14227$175/sf
996 sales
14086$203/sf
953 sales
14051$195/sf
910 sales
14026$189/sf
907 sales
14211$79/sf
862 sales
14214$149/sf
821 sales
14031$214/sf
799 sales
14085$187/sf
797 sales
14052$218/sf
735 sales
14068$194/sf
716 sales
14228$192/sf
689 sales
14213$102/sf
646 sales
14260$184/sf
578 sales
14222$176/sf
515 sales
14208$73/sf
507 sales
14059$200/sf
501 sales
14212$82/sf
481 sales
14261$182/sf
478 sales
14201$141/sf
469 sales
14210$92/sf
430 sales
14032$209/sf
382 sales
14004$179/sf
350 sales
14006$139/sf
320 sales
14001$167/sf
304 sales
14057$164/sf
292 sales
14047$144/sf
282 sales
14141$133/sf
275 sales
14061$137/sf
255 sales
14209$140/sf
233 sales
14102$192/sf
223 sales
14170$208/sf
199 sales
14204$86/sf
170 sales
14025$178/sf
162 sales
14080$151/sf
149 sales
14112$181/sf
130 sales
14111$111/sf
121 sales
14033$173/sf
112 sales
14202$315/sf
92 sales
14139$184/sf
89 sales
14069$161/sf
76 sales
14169$187/sf
66 sales
14203$68/sf
57 sales
14030$141/sf
55 sales
14034$124/sf
46 sales
14055$155/sf
45 sales
14168$111/sf
41 sales
14134$152/sf
41 sales
14035$127/sf
36 sales
14027$121/sf
34 sales
By home type
| Home type | Sales | Median $/sq ft | Median size | Median price |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Single-family | 38,495 | $176 | 1,527 sf | $260,000 |
| Multi-family | 7,448 | $96 | 2,162 sf | $200,000 |
Recent sales across Erie County
| Type | Sq ft | Sale price | $/sq ft | Yr built | Sold |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Single-family | 7,694 | $2,750,000 | $357 | 1932 | 2/2026 |
| Single-family | 4,409 | $1,510,000 | $343 | 2004 | 3/2026 |
| Single-family | 3,178 | $1,450,000 | $456 | 2015 | 4/2026 |
| Single-family | 2,949 | $1,395,000 | $473 | 1964 | 3/2026 |
| Single-family | 5,505 | $1,250,000 | $227 | 1917 | 2/2026 |
| Single-family | 6,186 | $1,250,000 | $202 | 2014 | 2/2026 |
| Single-family | 2,260 | $1,200,000 | $531 | 2023 | 1/2026 |
| Single-family | 4,525 | $1,085,000 | $240 | 2007 | 1/2026 |
| Single-family | 4,110 | $980,000 | $238 | 1995 | 1/2026 |
| Single-family | 2,774 | $975,000 | $352 | 2017 | 1/2026 |
| Single-family | 4,146 | $935,000 | $226 | 1927 | 3/2026 |
| Single-family | 4,644 | $930,000 | $200 | 1989 | 3/2026 |
| Single-family | 3,805 | $925,000 | $243 | 1915 | 1/2026 |
| Single-family | 3,424 | $925,000 | $270 | 1880 | 2/2026 |
| Single-family | 3,777 | $910,000 | $241 | 1986 | 1/2026 |
Appraising a site in Erie County?
Threshold US Land turns these comparables into an achievable new-build price and the maximum land bid that hits your margin. Reserve founding access for New York.
Reserve founding access →All New York counties & ZIPs →
Method: arms-length residential sales with assessor living area (2021+) from New York State ORPTS recorded sales joined to the state parcel-centroid layer for living area, plus the New York City annualized sales dataset for the five boroughs. $/sq ft is sale price over heated living area. Estimates for site screening, not a USPAP appraisal. Updated July 2026.